侯丹丹;罗明;郝洛西;林燕丹;
HOU Dandan;LUO Ming;HAO Luoxi;LIN Yandan;Department of Lighting Sources and Engineering, School of Information Science and Technology, Fudan University;Institute for Electric Light Sources, Fudan University, Engineering Research Center of Advanced Lighting Technology, Ministry of Education;College of Optical Science and Engineering, Zhejiang University;College of Architecture and Urban Planning, Tongji University;

• 1:复旦大学信息科学与工程学院光源与照明工程系
• 2:复旦大学电光源研究所
• 3:浙江大学光电科学与工程学院
• 4:同济大学建筑与城市规划学院

摘要(Abstract)：

本文汇总了28种常用测试人体健康评价方法,涉及对视觉绩效、视觉感受、视觉疲劳、警觉度、情绪、睡眠质量等6种人体健康指标的评价。在此基础上,根据各种方法是否能够在不同强度、光谱及光分布的光环境条件下表现出良好的响应灵敏度(响应度),以及对光环境的干扰程度(匹配度),定义各方法在光环境研究中的适用度,从而为进一步开展光环境人因工效学实验方法的选取提供依据。
This paper summarizes 28 commonly used human health evaluation methods, involving the evaluation of 6 human health indicators such as visual performance, visual perception, visual fatigue, alertness, mood, and sleep quality. On this basis, the applicability of various method in lighting research is defined as the response sensitivity(response degree) of methods under different lighting conditions of different intensity, spectrum, light distribution, and the degree of interference to the light environment(matching degree), to provide a basis for the experimental methods' selection for human factors research in lighting environment.

关键词(KeyWords)： 光环境;人体健康指标;响应灵敏度;匹配度;适用度
lighting environment;human health metrics;response sensitivity;matching degree;applicability

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家重点研发计划“战略性先进点子材料”重点专项“面向健康照明的光生物机理及应用研究”(项目编号:2017YFB0403700)

作者(Authors): 侯丹丹;罗明;郝洛西;林燕丹;
HOU Dandan;LUO Ming;HAO Luoxi;LIN Yandan;Department of Lighting Sources and Engineering, School of Information Science and Technology, Fudan University;Institute for Electric Light Sources, Fudan University, Engineering Research Center of Advanced Lighting Technology, Ministry of Education;College of Optical Science and Engineering, Zhejiang University;College of Architecture and Urban Planning, Tongji University;

参考文献(References)：

• [1] Souman J L,Borra T,De Goijer I,et al.Spectral tuning of white light allows for strong reduction in melatonin suppression without changing illumination level or color temperature[J].Journal of Biological Rhythms,2018,33(4):420-431.
• [2] Ru T,De Kort Y a W,Smolders K C H J,et al.Non-image forming effects of illuminance and correlated color temperature of office light on alertness,mood,and performance across cognitive domains[J].Building and Environment,2019,149:253-263.
• [3] Boyce P R.Review:The impact of light in buildings on human health[J].Indoor and Built Environment,2010,19(1):8-20.
• [4] Brickenkamp R,Cubero N S.d2,test de atención:manual[M].TEA Ediciones,2002.
• [5] Zillmer E A,Kennedy C H.Construct validity for the d2 test of attention[J].Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology,1999,14(8):728.
• [6] Dinges D F,Powell J W.Microcomputer analyses of performance on a portable,simple visual RT task during sustained operations[J].Behavior Research Methods,Instruments,& Computers,1985,17(6):652-655.
• [7] Kirchner,Wayne K.Age differences in short-term retention of rapidly changing information[J].J Exp Psychol,1958,55(4):352-358.
• [8] Rosvold H E,Mirsky A F,Sarason I,et al.A continuous performance test of brain damage[J].Journal of Consulting Psychology,1956,20(5):343.
• [9] Guignard J C,Bittner A C,Einbender S W,et al.Performance evaluation tests for environmental research (PETER):Landolt C reading test[J].Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting,1980,24(1):335-339.
• [10] Nagels G,Geentjens L,Kos D,et al.Paced visual serial addition test in multiple sclerosis[J].Clinical Neurology & Neurosurgery,2005,107(3):218-222.
• [11] Fos L A,Greve K W,South M B,et al.Paced visual serial addition test:an alternative measure of information processing speed[J].Applied Neuropsychology,2000,7(3):140-146.
• [12] Seagull F J,Sutton E,Lee T,et al.A validated subjective rating of display quality:the Maryland Visual Comfort Scale[J].Surgical Endoscopy,2011,25(2):567-571.
• [13] Vogels I.Atmosphere metrics:development of a tool to quantify experienced atmosphere[J].Probing Experience:From Assessment of User Emotions and Behaviour to Development of Products,2008:25-41.
• [14] Wang H H,Luo M R,Liu P,et al.A study of atmosphere perception of dynamic coloured light[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2014,46(6):661-675.
• [15] Liu X,Luo M,Li H.A study of atmosphere perceptions in a living room[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2015,47(5):581-594.
• [16] Lu Y,Li W,Xu W,et al.Impacts of LED dynamic white lighting on atmosphere perception[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2019,51(8):1143-1158.
• [17] Xue P,Mak C M,Cheung H D.The effects of daylighting and human behavior on luminous comfort in residential buildings:A questionnaire survey[J].Building and Environment,2014,81:51-59.
• [18] Chi C F,Lin F T.A comparison of seven visual fatigue assessment techniques in three data-acquisition VDT tasks[J].Human Factors,1998,40(4):577.
• [19] Lin P H,Lin Y T,Hwang S L,et al.Effects of anti-glare surface treatment,ambient illumination and bending curvature on legibility and visual fatigue of electronic papers[J].Displays,2008,29(1):25-32.
• [20] Heuer,Hollendiek,Kr?ger,et al.Die Ruhelage der Augen und ihr Einfluss auf Beobachtungsabstand und visuelle Ermüdung bei Bildschirmarbeit[J].Zeitschrift Für Experimentelle Und Angewandte Psychologie,1989,36:538-566.
• [21] Kuze J,Ukai K.Subjective evaluation of visual fatigue caused by motion images[J].Displays,2008,29(2):159-166.
• [22] Benloucif S,Guico M,Reid K J,et al.Stability of melatonin and temperature as circadian phase markers and their relation to sleep times in humans[J].Journal of Biological Rhythms,2005,20(2):178-188.
• [23] Arendt J.Melatonin and human rhythms[J].Chronobiology International,2006,23(1-2):21-37.
• [24] Dijk D J,Duffy J F,Czeisler C A.Circadian and sleep/wake dependent aspects of subjective alertness and cognitive performance[J].Journal of Sleep Research,1992,1(2):112-117.
• [25] Akerstedt T,Gillberg M.Subjective and objective sleepiness in the active individual[J].International Journal of Neuroscience,1990,52(1-2):29-37.
• [26] Horne J A,Baulk S D.Awareness of sleepiness when driving[J].Psychophysiology,2004,41(1):161-165.
• [27] Kaida K,Takahashi M,?kerstedt T,et al.Validation of the Karolinska sleepiness scale against performance and EEG variables[J].Clinical Neurophysiology,2006,117(7):1574-1581.
• [28] Hoddes E,Dement W,Zarcone V.The development and use of the Stanford sleepiness scale (SSS)[J].Psychophysiology,1972,10:431-436.
• [29] Joel H,Roger B.Sensitivity of the stanford sleepiness scale to the effects of cumulative partial sleep deprivation and recovery oversleeping[J].Sleep,1981(1):83.
• [30] Johns M.A new method for measuring daytime sleepiness:the epworth sleepiness scale[J].Sleep,1992,14:540-5.
• [31] Cabanac M.What is emotion?[J].Behavioural Processes,2003,60(2):69-83.
• [32] Berntson G G,Bigger J T,Eckberg D L,et al.Heart rate variability:origins,methods,and interpretive caveats[J].Psychophysiology,1997,34(6):623-648.
• [33] Porges S W.The polyvagal perspective[J].Biological Psychology,2007,74(2):116-143.
• [34] Quintana D S,Guastella A J,Outhred T,et al.Heart rate variability is associated with emotion recognition:Direct evidence for a relationship between the autonomic nervous system and social cognition[J].International Journal of Psychophysiology,2012,86(2):168-172.
• [35] Lang P.Behavioral treatment and bio-behavioral assessment:computer applications[J].Technology in Mental Health Care Delivery Systems,1980:119-137.
• [36] Bradley M M,Lang P J.Measuring emotion:the self-assessment manikin and the semantic differential[J].J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry,1994,25(1):49-59.
• [37] Mehrabian A,Russell J A.An approach to environmental psychology[M].Cambridge,MA,US:The MIT Press,1974.
• [38] Lang P J,Bradley M M,Cuthbert B N.Emotion,attention,and the startle reflex[J].Psychological Review,1990,97(3):377.
• [39] Spielberger C D.Review of profile of mood states[J].Professional Psychology,1972,3(4):387-388.
• [40] M.D A,Ph.D K,M.D S,et al.Profile of Mood States (POMS),STOP,THAT and One Hundred Other Sleep Scales[M].New York,NY:Springer,2011.
• [41] Watson D,Clark L A,Tellegen A.Development and validation of brief measures of positive and negative affect-the panas scales[J].Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1988,54(6):1063-1070.
• [42] Ibáňez V,Silva J,Cauli O.A survey on sleep assessment methods[J].PeerJ,2018,6:e4849.
• [43] Orr William C.Utilization of polysomnography in the assessment of sleep disorders[J].Med Clin North Am,1985,69(6):1153-1167.
• [44] Buysse D J,Reynolds Iii C F,Monk T H,et al.The Pittsburgh sleep quality index:a new instrument for psychiatric practice and research[J].Psychiatry Research,1989,28(2):193-213.
• [45] Kato T.Development of the sleep quality questionnaire in healthy adults[J].Journal of Health Psychology,2014,19(8):977-986.
• [46] Gomes A A,Marques D R,Meia-Via A M,et al.Basic scale on insomnia complaints and quality of sleep (BaSIQS):reliability,initial validity and normative scores in higher education students[J].Chronobiology International,2015,32(3):428-440.
• [47] Mulder-Hajonides Van Der Meulen W,Wijnberg J,Hollander J,et al.Measurement of subjective sleep quality[C]// Proceedings of the International European Sleep Congress,1981.
• [48] Kindt S,Van De Putte E,Bracke P,et al.Human centric lighting:the impact of light on sleep and attention of factory shift workers[J].European Journal of Public Health,2020,30(Supplement_5):ckaa166.450.
• [49] Keis O,Helbig H,Streb J,et al.Influence of blue-enriched classroom lighting on students’ cognitive performance[J].Trends in Neuroscience and Education,2014,3(3):86-92.
• [50] Toftum J,Thorseth A,Markvart J,et al.Occupant response to different correlated colour temperatures of white LED lighting[J].Building and Environment,2018,143:258-268.
• [51] Liu Y,Luo M R,Wu P,et al.The impact of E mel range of dynamic lighting on alertness,fatigue and sleeping quality[C]// 2019 16th China International Forum on Solid State Lighting & 2019 International Forum on Wide Bandgap Semiconductors China (SSLChina:IFWS),2019.
• [52] Phipps-Nelson J,Redman J R,Dijk D J,et al.Daytime exposure to bright light,as compared to dim light,decreases sleepiness and improves psychomotor vigilance performance[J].Sleep,2003,26(6):695-700.
• [53] Sletten T L,Ftouni S,Nicholas C L,et al.Randomised controlled trial of the efficacy of a blue-enriched light intervention to improve alertness and performance in night shift workers[J].Occupational and Environmental Medicine,2017,74(11):792-801.
• [54] Rahman S A,St Hilaire M A,Lockley S W.The effects of spectral tuning of evening ambient light on melatonin suppression,alertness and sleep[J].Physiology & Behavior,2017,177:221-229.
• [55] Chellappa S L,Steiner R,Blattner P,et al.Non-visual effects of light on melatonin,alertness and cognitive performance:can blue-enriched light keep us alert?[J].Plos One,2011,6(1):11.
• [56] Griepentrog J E,Labiner H E,Gunn S R,et al.Bright environmental light improves the sleepiness of nightshift ICU nurses[J].Critical Care,2018,22(1):295.
• [57] Ru T,Smolders K C,Chen Q,et al.Diurnal effects of illuminance on performance:exploring the moderating role of cognitive domain and task difficulty[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2021:1477153521990645.
• [58] Ye M,Zheng S Q,Wang M L,et al.The effect of dynamic correlated colour temperature changes on alertness and performance[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2018,50(7):1070-1081.
• [59] Gabel V,Maire M,Reichert C F,et al.Effects of artificial dawn and morning blue light on daytime cognitive performance,well-being,cortisol and melatonin levels[J].Chronobiology International,2013,30(8):988-997.
• [60] Munch M,Linhart F,Borisuit A,et al.Effects of prior light exposure on early evening performance,subjective sleepiness,and hormonal secretion[J].Behavioral Neuroscience,2012,126(1):196-203.
• [61] Motamedzadeh M,Golmohammadi R,Kazemi R,et al.The effect of blue-enriched white light on cognitive performances and sleepiness of night-shift workers:a field study[J].Physiology & Behavior,2017,177:208-214.
• [62] Green A,Cohen-Zion M,Haim A,et al.Evening light exposure to computer screens disrupts human sleep,biological rhythms,and attention abilities[J].Chronobiology International,2017,34(7):855-865.
• [63] Mohebian Z,Farhang Dehghan S,Dehghan H.Evaluation of the combined effects of heat and lighting on the level of attention and reaction time:climate chamber experiments in iran[J].The Scientific World Journal,2018,2018-5171582:7.
• [64] Berman S,Fein G,Jewett D,et al.Landolt-C recognition in elderly subjects is affected by scotopic intensity of surround illuminants[J].Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society,1994,23(2):123-130.
• [65] Berman S,Jewett D,Fein G,et al.Lighting spectral effect on Landolt C performance is enhanced by blur and abolished by mydriasis[J].Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society,1996,25(1):42-50.
• [66] Boyce P R.Age,illuminance,visual performance and preference[J].Lighting Research & Technology,1973,5(3):125-144.
• [67] Wang A H,Kuo H T,Jeng S C.Effects of ambient illuminance on users’ visual performance using various electronic displays[J].Journal of the Society for Information Display,2009,17(8):665-669.
• [68] Wang A H,Hwang S L,Kuo H T.Effects of bending curvature and ambient illuminance on the visual performance of young and elderly participants using simulated electronic paper displays[J].Displays,2012,33(1):36-41.
• [69] Schlangen L,Verhaegh J,Denissen A.Workplace illumination effects on acuity corgnitive performance and well-being in older and young people[C]//Proceedings of the 28th CIE SESSION (CIE 216:2015),2015.
• [70] Veitch J A,Mccoll S L.Modulation of fluorescent light:flicker rate and light source effects on visual performance and visual comfort[J].International Journal of Lighting Research and Technology,1995,27(4):243-256.
• [71] Ru T,De Kort Y A,Smolders K C,et al.Non-image forming effects of illuminance and correlated color temperature of office light on alertness,mood,and performance across cognitive domains[J].Building and Environment,2019,149:253-263.
• [72] Hou D,Dai C,Lu Y,et al.Effects of illumination and color temperature distribution on subjective perception[C]// 2019 16th China International Forum on Solid State Lighting & 2019 International Forum on Wide Bandgap Semiconductors China (SSLChina:IFWS),2019.
• [73] Chellappa S L,Steiner R,Blattner P,et al.Non-visual effects of light on melatonin,alertness and cognitive performance:can blue-enriched light keep us alert?[J].PloS one,2011,6(1):e16429.
• [74] Seagull F J,Sutton E,Lee T,et al.A validated subjective rating of display quality:the Maryland Visual Comfort Scale[J].Surgical Endoscopy and Other Interventional Techniques,2011,25(2):567-571.
• [75] Linhart F,Scartezzini J L.Evening office lighting-visual comfort vs.energy efficiency vs.performance?[J].Building and Environment,2011,46(5):981-989.
• [76] Regente J,De Zeeuw J,Bes F,et al.Can short-wavelength depleted bright light during single simulated night shifts prevent circadian phase shifts?[J].Applied Ergonomics,2017,61:22-30.
• [77] Borisuit A,Linhart F,Scartezzini J L,et al.Effects of realistic office daylighting and electric lighting conditions on visual comfort,alertness and mood[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2015,47(2):192-209.
• [78] Castilla N,Llinares C,Bisegna F,et al.Affective evaluation of the luminous environment in university classrooms[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,2018,58:52-62.
• [79] Hansen E K,Pajuste M,Xylakis E.Flow of light:Balancing directionality and CCT in the office environment[J].LEUKOS,2020:1-22.
• [80] Stokkermans M G,Chen Y,Murdoch M J,et al.Effect of daylight on atmosphere perception:comparison of a real space and visualizations[C]// Human Vision and Electronic Imaging XX,2015.
• [81] Zhao X,Hou D,Lin Y,et al.The effect of stroboscopic effect on human health indicators[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2020,52(3):389-406.
• [82] Chang P C,Chou S Y,Shieh K K.Reading performance and visual fatigue when using electronic paper displays in long-duration reading tasks under various lighting conditions[J].Displays,2013,34(3):208-214.
• [83] Buchner A,Baumgartner N.Text-background polarity affects performance irrespective of ambient illumination and colour contrast[J].Ergonomics,2007,50(7):1036-1063.
• [84] Benedetto S,Carbone A,Drai-Zerbib V,et al.Effects of luminance and illuminance on visual fatigue and arousal during digital reading[J].Computers in Human Behavior,2014,41:112-119.
• [85] Mayr S,K?pper M,Buchner A.Comparing colour discrimination and proofreading performance under compact fluorescent and halogen lamp lighting[J].Ergonomics,2013,56(9):1418-1429.
• [86] Wang P C,Hwang S L,Chen C S,et al.Luminance effects influencing perception of 3-D TV imagery[J].Journal of the Society for Information Display,2012,20(4):197-207.
• [87] Guo J,Weng D,Duh H BL,et al.Effects of using HMDs on visual fatigue in virtual environments[C]// 2017 IEEE Virtual Reality (VR),2017.
• [88] Shin Y B,Woo S H,Kim D H,et al.The effect on emotions and brain activity by the direct/indirect lighting in the residential environment[J].Neuroscience Letters,2015,584:28-32.
• [89] Smolders K,De Kort Y,Cluitmans P.Higher light intensity induces modulations in brain activity even during regular daytime working hours[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2016,48(4):433-448.
• [90] Siemiginowska P,Iskra-Golec I.Blue light effect on EEG activity-the role of exposure timing and chronotype[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2019,52(4):472-484.
• [91] Sahin L,Figueiro M G.Alerting effects of short-wavelength (blue) and long-wavelength (red) lights in the afternoon[J].Physiology & Behavior,2013,116:1-7.
• [92] Küller R,Wetterberg L.Melatonin,cortisol,EEG,ECG and subjective comfort in healthy humans:impact of two fluorescent lamp types at two light intensities[J].International Journal of Lighting Research and Technology,1993,25(2):71-80.
• [93] Yagi A,Imanishi S,Konishi H,et al.Brain potentials associated with eye fixations during visual tasks under different lighting systems[J].Ergonomics,1998,41(5):670-677.
• [94] Kraneburg A,Franke S,Methling R,et al.Effect of color temperature on melatonin production for illumination of working environments[J].Applied Ergonomics,2017,58:446-453.
• [95] Najjar R P,Zeitzer J M.Temporal integration of light flashes by the human circadian system[J].Journal of Clinical Investigation,2016,126(3):938-947.
• [96] Green A,Cohen-Zion M,Haim A,et al.Comparing the response to acute and chronic exposure to short wavelength lighting emitted from computer screens[J].Chronobiology International,2018,35(1):90-100.
• [97] Sadeghniiat H K,Yazdi Z,Jahanihashemi H,et al.The effect of bright light on sleepiness among rapid-rotating 12-hour shift workers[J].Scandinavian Journal of Work Environment & Health,2011,37(1):77-79.
• [98] Raikes A C,Dailey N S,Shane B R,et al.Daily morning blue light therapy improves daytime sleepiness,sleep quality,and quality of life following a mild traumatic brain injury[J].The Journal of Head Trauma Rehabilitation,2020,35(5):E405-E421.
• [99] Seo H S,Kim J T.The effect of illuminance and color temperature of LED lighting on occupants’ perception and HRV[J].■,2015,15(2):37-43.
• [100] Araujo J,Rodrigues M J,Postolache O,et al.Heart rate variability analysis in healthy subjects under different colored lighting conditions[C]//2020 IEEE International Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference (I2MTC),2020.
• [101] Kim D H,Kim C,Lee S M,et al.73-3:Invited paper:influences of circadian illuminances from lighting and TV on the human locomotor activity,sleep disorder,EEG,HRV,and melatonin secretion[C]// SID Symposium Digest of Technical Papers,2020.
• [102] Moharreri S,Rezaei S,Dabanloo N J,et al.Study of induced emotion by color stimuli:power spectrum analysis of heart rate variability[C]//Computing in Cardiology 2014,2014.
• [103] Porcu S,Floris A,Atzori L.Towards the evaluation of the effects of ambient illumination and noise on quality of experience[C]// 2019 Eleventh International Conference on Quality of Multimedia Experience (QoMEX),2019.
• [104] Lee H,Lee E.Effects of coloured lighting on pleasure and arousal in relation to cultural differences[J].Lighting Research & Technology,2021:1477153521999592.
• [105] Quartier K,Vanrie J,Van Cleempoel K.As real as it gets:what role does lighting have on consumer’s perception of atmosphere,emotions and behaviour?[J].Journal of Environmental Psychology,2014,39:32-39.
• [106] De Vries A,Souman J L,De Ruyter B,et al.Lighting up the office:the effect of wall luminance on room appraisal,office workers’ performance,and subjective alertness[J].Building and Environment,2018,142:534-543.
• [107] Bernhofer E I,Higgins P A,Daly B J,et al.Hospital lighting and its association with sleep,mood and pain in medical inpatients[J].Journal of Advanced Nursing,2014,70(5):1164-1173.
• [108] Royer M,Ballentine N H,Eslinger P J,et al.Light therapy for seniors in long term care[J].Journal of the American Medical Directors Association,2012,13(2):100-102.
• [109] O’brien P M,O’conner P J.Effect of bright light on cycling performance[J].Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,2000,32(2):439-447.
• [110] Knez I,Enmarker I.Effects of office lighting on mood and cognitive performance and a gender effect in work-xRelated judgment[J].Environment & Behavior,1998,30(4):553-567.
• [111] Boyce P R,Eklund N H,Simpson S N.Individual lighting control:task performance,mood,and illuminance[J].Journal of the Illuminating Engineering Society,2000,29(1):131-142.
• [112] Figueiro M G,Steverson B,Heerwagen J,et al.The impact of daytime light exposures on sleep and mood in office workers[J].Sleep Health,2017,3(3):204-215.
• [113] Luo M R,Wang M,Liu Y.The impact of LED lighting on People’s work performance between different age groups[C]// 2018 15th China International Forum on